Whatever happened to Scraped Knees?
Have you been to a neighborhood park lately and simply watched children play? There are a couple of children on the swings, pushed by a parent; another little one being encouraged down the slide; and another quietly playing in the sand—with a parent close by, of course.
Childhood experiences have undoubtedly changed with every generation. The toys children use for imaginative play have changed, as have the games they play and the spaces in which they play them. Playtime has evolved from running after one another or chasing chickens around a farm, to rolling an old car tire down the road with a stick, riding oversized bicycles, playing organized sports and, more recently, disappearing into the world of digital games.
Even the ground beneath children's feet has changed. The humble backyard, perhaps with its homemade skating rink in winter, gradually gave way to concrete tarmacs, carefully designed playgrounds and now artificial turf.
Today, when I watch children play, they certainly seem to be enjoying themselves. Yet I cannot help noticing that their play is no longer quite as unfiltered as it once was. There seems to be an adult nearby—watching, guiding, helping, cautioning, protecting.
Recently, at that same park, I watched a young child learning to roller blade. He wore a helmet, elbow pads and knee pads, and held tightly to his father's hand as he moved gingerly forward. There was nothing particularly unusual about the scene. In fact, it was probably exactly what most of us would consider responsible parenting.
And yet, it made me wonder: Are we raising risk-averse children?
What happened to the children who climbed trees and jumped off branches, gleefully chased a hare across a field, or ran so wildly that they landed headfirst in a thorny bush?
I remember learning to ride a bicycle when I was ten, with another equally confident ten-year-old showing me the ropes. Before long, I was racing across a field—until I rode straight into a dense hedge. I emerged laughing, my face scratched, my knee bruised and a sizeable gash on my elbow.
I went home quietly. My friend, feeling somewhat responsible for the mishap, helped me wash the wound and carefully peeled the plastic off a Band-Aid.
Did my mother know?
Only if I told her.
Today, that story would probably have a very different ending.
Of course, safety matters. Helmets save children from serious injuries. Seatbelts, playground standards and sensible supervision exist for good reason. I am certainly not suggesting that we send children out looking for thorny bushes to fall into.
But somewhere between protecting children from real danger and protecting them from every possible risk, have we crossed a line?
A scraped knee, a tumble, a failed attempt to climb a little higher, or the frightening wobble of a bicycle when no adult hand is holding on—these are not merely childhood mishaps. They are also experiences through which children discover their own limits, judge risk, solve problems, recover from failure and, perhaps most importantly, learn: I can handle this.
Safety is important.
But are we carrying it too far?
Comments